William Graham Sumner Essay

Related Essays

William Graham Sumner
William Graham Sumner was born in Patterson, New Jersey on October 30th, 1940. He grew up in Hartford, Connecticut with his sturdy, working-class, English immigrant
Alexander Graham Bell Essay 12
to do thing following a specific theory. To close this essay if not for the greatness of Mr. Alexander Graham Bell the communication world as we know it today
Alexander Graham Bell Essay 3
first flight Bell formed the Aerial Experiment Association with Glenn Curtiss, William "Casey" Baldwin, Thomas Selfridge, and J.A.D. McCurdy, four young engineers
Alexander Graham Bell Essay 14
where creativity and new ideas were embraced with vigor was to certainly contribute to Alexander Graham Bell's genius later on in life (Winefield 12). Young Bell

Submitted by to the category Philosophy and Psychology on 11/29/2010 01:19 PM

William Graham Sumner Essay

William Graham Sumner argued that what our conscience tells us depends solely upon our social group. The moral values we hold are not part of our moral nature, according to Sumner. They are part of our training and upbringing. Sumner argued in his book, Folkways: "World philosophy, life policy, right, rights, and morality are all products of the folkways.” In other words, what we perceive as conscience is merely the product of culture upon our minds through childhood training and cultural influence. There are no universal ethical principles, merely different cultural conditioning.

Sumner studied all sorts of societies (primitive and advanced), and was able to document numerous examples of cultural relativism. Although many cultures promoted the idea, for example, that a man could have many wives, Sumner discovered that in Tibet a woman was encouraged to have many husbands. He also described how some Eskimo tribes allowed deformed babies to die by being exposed to the elements. In the Fiji Islands, aged parents were killed.

Sumner believed that this diversity of moral values clearly demonstrated that culture is the sole determinant of our ethical standards. In essence, culture determines what is right and wrong. And different cultures come to different ethical conclusions. Proponents of cultural relativism believe this cultural diversity proves that culture alone is responsible for our morality. There is no soul or spirit or mind or conscience. Moral relativists say that what we perceive as moral convictions or conscience are the byproducts of culture.

The strength of cultural relativism is that it allows us to withhold moral judgments about the social practices of another culture. In fact, proponents of cultural relativism would say that to pass judgment on another culture would be ethnocentric. This strength, however, is also a major weakness. Cultural relativism excuses us from judging the moral practices of another culture. Yet...

View Full Essay
Full Essay Stats...
  • Words: 737
  • Pages: 3
  • Views: 924

Join now to view this essay and thousands of others on PaperCamp.com. It's free Join Now!