Walmart vs Samara Bros

Related Essays

Sustainability: Walmart Vs. Starbucks
Business Models: Walmart vs. Starbucks Introduction Sustainability has become a great topic of interest in many arenas
Walmart Vs. Target
can cause customer service issues. According to comScore Media Metrix analysts; Walmart.com is distinctly back of the pack in terms of total online sales, ranking
Walmart Vs Big Bazar
2009, it generated 51% of its US$258 billion sales in the U.S. from grocery business. Walmart has 8,500 stores in 15 countries, under 55 different names. HISTORY
Walmart Vs Target Financial Analysis
iii 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., branded as Walmart, is an American multinational retail corporation that runs chains of large discount

Submitted by to the category Business and Industry on 03/15/2013 07:33 AM

Review and History of Supreme Court Case titled

Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Samara Brothers, Inc.

Lee Dupree

Prof. Michael Hanners

LEG 565

Commercial Law

08/08/12

Before the Case

Ultimately, the goal of trade dress protection has always been to prevent other manufacturers from making one product look like another, therefore deceiving unaware consumers into purchasing goods from the wrong manufacturer. By the end of the 1990s, courts also began to protect product shapes and packaging. The broad label of unfair competition supplied product packaging and shapes with legal protection, known as trade dress. Trade dress was meant to make it easier for consumers to differentiate products by their dress and associate a product and its manufacturer with the dress as well. By default, this protection extended to protect the producer’s investment in the advertising and promotion of the product, and also allowed producers to sue on behalf of consumers who would have a difficult time bringing suit based on their confusion.

Samara Brothers, Inc. designs and produces clothing for children and the most profitable part of its business was spring and summer one piece outfits that display items such as hearts or flowers. In 1995, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. contacted one of its suppliers, Judy-Phillipine, Inc. and contracted them to produce an entire line of children’s clothing patterned after photographs of Samara clothes. (It should be noted that Judy-Phillipe, Inc. supplied the clothing line to K-Mart, Caldor, Hills, and Goody’s also.) In 1996, a J.C. Penny consumer informed Samara that its exact designs were being sold by Walt-Mart at lower prices than J.C. Penny was contracted to offer; this acted as Samara’s discovery that Wal-Mart was selling their designs. Samara sent cease-and-desist letters and then sued Wal-Mart, Judy-Phillipine, K-Mart, Caldor, Hills, and Goody’s for copyright infringement, consumer fraud, and infringement of unregistered trade dress...

View Full Essay
Full Essay Stats...
  • Words: 1637
  • Pages: 7
  • Views: 291

Join now to view this essay and thousands of others on PaperCamp.com. It's free Join Now!