Essay One Analysis

Essay #1 | February 18

2011

|

POL 507; Professor Tanner Mirrlees | By Tohru James Miyamoto 500300772 |

Harpaz, Beth J., Are we raising a generation of nincompoops? Topeka Capital Journal. Topeka Kansas. Sept. 28, 2010. P. 6.

Article summary

The article chosen describes how the younger generation is becoming inept at common tasks that we do in everyday circumstances, even the title suggests it, “Are we raising a generation of nincompoops?” Predominately, the older generation, usually baby boomers, often take kids for granted. However, for the most part, the youth is adept at use of technology that is “digital,” in nature to those from past generation. Ultimately, in a healthy society, there is supposed to be a natural tension between the older and younger generations. It is how society has been brought up. It is up to the adult to remind the kid that, “The world didn’t begin on their 13th birthday!” And it’s good for kids to begrudge adults and fight back. Parents want to be critical and hassle them. This is considered beneficial in a well functioning society, but it not considered constructive to be passive and let “kids be kids because they grow up”.

Introduction

The main view proposed by the author is that kids growing up now are becoming lazy due to their dependence on technology. The argument is emphasized by her pessimistic determinist argument. This is evident when, she introduces the contention that kids from various age groups are unskilled at routine tasks. Such as, the use of pull up diapers for four year olds as opposed to regular pin up type. And, second graders who are not able to tie shoes or zip jackets. In addition, teenagers who are not able to operate can openers. And finally, college aged youth who cannot do laundry; take public transit alone, or address an envelope.

The author’s take in the article

The author goes on to state her determinist argument that technology is what shapes the actions of the younger generation. To...