Case Study

Immigration Reform for Economic Growth and Worker Protection

While at one time the United States boasted of being a “nation of immigrants” it now emphasizes being a “nation of laws.” Laws which affect our country’s well-being such as those regarding immigration reform are an ongoing heated debate. In the words of President Barack Obama (2009) regarding illegal immigration and immigration reform: “Laws must be binding; rules must be followed; words must mean something” (Briggs, 2010).

Reforming immigration laws can boost the economy and foster stability. Given the ongoing economic crisis, it would be wise to support measures that contribute to a reversal. Although reform measures may carry a hefty price tag for a period of 10 years to the GDP, “the wage for all workers will be lifted” (Fitz & Martinez, 2010).

Moreover, immigration policy reform will protect workers from exploitation and unfair competition. In states such as Arizona, a large population of illegal immigrants are paid in cash and untaxed, working menial jobs that most American citizens would not care to work. These immigrants also work at the lowest rates that aren’t feasible for the average American citizen (Ryland, 2010).

According to Fitz and Martinez:

“Comprehensive immigration reform is backed by business, labor, law enforcement, and faith communities who recognize its importance to keeping our communities productive and safe, ensuring fairness to workers and employers, and upholding family and community values. More than 700 organizations in almost 40 states are mobilized and will hold their leaders accountable” (2010).

Briggs explains that “Illegal immigration disproportionately and adversely affects the economic well-being of the most vulnerable and needy segment of the nation’s labor force: its low skilled workers (both those who are native-born and foreign-born)” (2010). Moreover, it continues to weaken the already substandard employment standards of the nation’s labor force. It...